Media & Insights

manufacturing & industrial

Working Capital Finance: Follow the Cash, Not the Order

See how lenders trace funds from approved suppliers through production, delivery, acceptance and customer payment.

GI Network Editorial
GI Network Editorial

Editorial desk

Published 22 November 2026
Hin Leong Trading oil storage infrastructure in Singapore
Photo: Prajwal / pexels

Manufacturers often assume that a confirmed order should unlock production funding. But lenders discount anything they cannot trace: disputed invoices, unaccepted deliveries, work in progress, slow stock, customer concentration and uncontrolled collections. From Katana Foods in South Africa to Hin Leong in Singapore, the failures show why. The practical answer is to build an operating evidence trail that lets a lender follow cash from order to supplier, factory, delivery, acceptance and payment.

Key takeaways
  • ·A purchase order can support controlled supplier payments, but it is not automatically cash collateral.
  • ·Lenders monitor proof of delivery, customer acceptance, payment source, stock location and collection-account control.
  • ·The usable amount of a facility comes from eligible receivables and inventory after exclusions, not from the headline value of orders or stock.
  • ·A high advance rate can conceal fees, legal uncertainty and the cost of waiting for the customer to pay.
  • ·Better production records, stock controls and debtor evidence can improve funding availability without adding property collateral.
  • ·The strongest finance proposal is an operating file that a lender can independently test.

In December 2017, South Africa’s Supreme Court of Appeal examined a financing arrangement that looked reassuring from the outside. Merchant Commercial Finance had advanced money against invoices from Katana Foods. A Katana employee had confirmed that goods were received. Earlier invoices had been repaid.

Then the story came apart.

The court found that 13 fictitious invoices had generated advances of more than R3 million. Repayments on earlier invoices had come from the supplier, not the supposed customer. The final three invoices caused a R404,557.26 loss. One advance had been paid before the debtor was verified.

That is not merely a fraud story. It is a funding story.

A manufacturer can have a real customer order, genuine materials and a respectable balance sheet, yet still fail the question that decides whether a lender releases money: can the lender see, verify and control the journey from its cash to the customer’s cash?

Most businesses think the asset is the purchase order. It is not. The asset is the controlled conversion.

The comforting myth of the confirmed order

Imagine you have won a R10 million order. The customer pays a R1 million deposit. Materials cost R5 million, with half payable on order and the rest before shipment. Conversion costs are R2 million. Production lasts 60 days. Scrap runs 8% above standard.

The peak funding need is R6.4 million.

Not R10 million. Not the value of the order. R6.4 million, at a particular point in time, before you have an accepted invoice.

This is where most people stop looking. They see a signed order and ask for finance equal to the order value. A lender sees a chain of risks: will the supplier deliver, does the manufacturer own the materials, can the factory complete the work, will the buyer accept it, and where will the payment land?

Standard Bank, the South African bank, makes that distinction unusually plainly in its provincial-government purchase-order facility. It validates the order with the issuer and pays approved suppliers directly. It excludes services, subcontracts, personal protective equipment and debt refinancing. Above R500,000, it requires a department-signed implementation plan. Its stated cap is R1.5 million, with a 14-working-day turnaround.

That is not instant cash against a piece of paper. It is controlled funding against a documented production path.

The invoice that fooled everyone

Katana Foods shows why lenders become so demanding about that path. A debtor confirmation sounded like proof. Previous repayments sounded like proof. Neither was proof of a genuine sale or a genuine customer payment.

The control lesson is simple, though doing it well is not: before an invoice is financed, the lender needs independent evidence of the order, dispatch, delivery, acceptance and payment source.

An invoice is a request for payment. It is not evidence that payment is certain.

The same lesson surfaced much more dramatically in Singapore. Hin Leong Trading, the oil-trading company founded by Lim Oon Kuin, used fabricated oil sales and forged documents to obtain invoice discounting from HSBC. Singapore Police said in November 2024 that Lim was sentenced to 17½ years after HSBC disbursed US$111.7 million. Court records also described non-existent inventory and the same inventory being sold to multiple parties.

Hin Leong Trading demonstrated the cost of relying on internally generated trade documents without independent proof of sales and inventory.

Hin Leong Trading demonstrated the cost of relying on internally generated trade documents without independent proof of sales and inventory. Photo: Prajwal / Pexels, Pexels licence (free commercial use).

At first glance, these cases look like exceptional criminal conduct. They are also the reason ordinary manufacturers face ordinary controls: site inspections, debtor checks, stock reports, bank-managed collection accounts and exclusions from borrowing calculations. The lender is not being fussy. It is trying to avoid funding an asset that exists only in a spreadsheet.

For deeper stock controls, see why secured stock is not automatically secure. Paper security cannot substitute for proof of title, location and condition.

What lenders actually count

Once goods are delivered and accepted, receivables finance can become available. But the headline invoice total is rarely the number that matters.

Take a borrowing-base example. Start with R20 million of gross receivables. Remove R2 million that is aged, R1 million that is disputed or exposed to credit notes, R1.5 million of uninsured foreign debt, R0.5 million owed by related parties and R3 million above a customer-concentration limit. That leaves R12 million. At an 80% advance rate, it supports R9.6 million.

Now take R15 million of inventory. Exclude R4 million of work in progress, R2 million of slow or obsolete stock, R1 million of consignment stock and R1 million for production and scrap. Advance 50% against the remaining R7 million. That produces R3.5 million. After a R1.1 million reserve, total availability is R12 million.

The accounting balance says R35 million. The fundable amount is R12 million.

That gap explains a common and painful surprise: a lender may approve a facility limit, but the business cannot draw the full amount in a particular month. The limit is the ceiling. Eligibility decides what is available today.

Absa, the South African bank, says receivables facilities can commonly advance up to 80%, but requires good controls and finance systems. It directs collections into a bank-managed clearing account and limits purchases to periods of up to 120 days. Where a borrower’s internal controls are less developed, factoring can be more suitable because the bank administers the sales ledger and collections.

That collection account matters more than it sounds. It tells the lender that customer cash will not disappear into a general operating account before the funded invoice is repaid.

The factory that made its evidence visible

VM Automotive, a South African automotive component manufacturer, offers the opposite kind of story. The Industrial Development Corporation approved R112 million in 2018 to acquire a Rosslyn blanking plant, support operating expenses and working capital, and fund upgrades.

The case was not built around carmaker orders alone. VM Automotive had long-duration BMW and Mercedes-Benz programmes, skilled staff, traceable imported steel and high-speed blanking equipment. It also quantified its recycling, reporting more than R5 million of steel and aluminium recycled in one financial year.

VM Automotive’s fundability rested on more than customer programmes: the case included traceable steel, production capability and documented

VM Automotive’s fundability rested on more than customer programmes: the case included traceable steel, production capability and documented scrap recovery. Photo: yunus alex / Pexels, Pexels licence (free commercial use).

The interesting part is not that recycling sounds virtuous. It is that scrap recovery made the production economics more visible. A lender could see material coming in, being processed, becoming product or recoverable scrap, and supporting contracted output.

Put VM Automotive beside Katana Foods and a pattern appears that neither case states outright. Fundability rises when the business reduces the number of moments at which an asset can become unverifiable. Traceable steel, identifiable equipment and documented scrap recovery narrow the room for uncertainty. A fictitious invoice and supplier-funded repayment widen it.

For manufacturers, the practical move is to document material ownership, supplier terms, expected scrap, production capacity, dispatch records and customer acceptance in one reconciled file. Read why lenders may lend less against concentration before assuming that one large, reliable customer automatically increases borrowing power.

When a legal claim is not enough

Zambia’s experience is a useful warning for anyone who believes registering security solves the problem. The country has a movable-collateral registry that permits claims over assets such as receivables and inventory. Yet the World Bank found that banks placed more importance on financial records than on collateral. Many applications failed before collateral was even appraised because applicants could not demonstrate cash flow, experience or financial performance.

Receivables and inventory represented only 12% of collateral reported in the 2019 Enterprise Survey. Lenders cited weak records, the risk that pledged assets could be sold, and the cost of inspection and disposal.

There was another distinction. ZESCO, an off-taker whose payment delays affected suppliers, made lenders retreat from some supplier receivables. Zambia Sugar, Lafarge Cement and Zambian Breweries, all named as reliable off-takers in the World Bank study, were viewed differently.

A borrower may have legal rights over stock. A lender still needs confidence that the stock is there, that it can be identified, and that customer proceeds can be captured. Legal security is a claim. Control is the ability to act on it.

In Botswana, Absa, the bank offering purchase-order finance, publishes funding of up to 80% of PO value, at prime plus 7%, with no conventional security. But the buyer must sign a deed of cession directing payment to Absa. The facility is not unsecured in the everyday sense. It substitutes control of the buyer’s payment for a conventional asset pledge.

The future invoice that was not an asset

Greensill Capital, the UK supply-chain finance company, pushed this distinction to its breaking point. UK and Australian parliamentary inquiries found that 11% of Greensill’s 2020 business related to future receivables. These were expected sales, not accepted invoices. The business also relied on trade-credit insurance, and the withdrawal of that insurance was a principal driver of its 2021 collapse.

Greensill Capital showed why future sales and trade-credit insurance cannot substitute for accepted, verifiable receivables.

Greensill Capital showed why future sales and trade-credit insurance cannot substitute for accepted, verifiable receivables. Photo: Prajwol Ghemosu / Pexels, Pexels licence (free commercial use).

Here is the twist: credit insurance can reduce the loss from a bad debt. It cannot make a receivable exist.

The temptation is understandable. A manufacturer knows a customer will probably keep buying. A lender sees a prediction whose timing, quantity and acceptance have not yet happened. Those are different things.

Master Trading v CapX Finance in Namibia adds a quieter warning. Pleadings described advances of 70% of invoice value, interest alleged at 5% per month or 0.167% per day, and N$250 per transaction. The dispute included whether the arrangement was a sale of debt or money lending. The decision was procedural, not a final ruling on the merits, but the point survives: a headline advance rate tells you very little about the true cost through the actual collection date.

Before signing, model fees, interest, transaction charges and late customer payment. Also establish the legal and accounting treatment. A fast assessment and a generous advance percentage can both be expensive.

What investors and lenders are really pricing

Lenders monitor three things: whether the asset exists, whether it will turn into cash, and whether that cash reaches them first.

They price uncertainty around those questions. A disputed invoice, a concentrated customer book, uninsured foreign debt, slow stock or weak records can reduce availability because each adds a chance that the asset will not convert as forecast. They reject transactions where proof is missing, proceeds are uncontrolled, or the same stock or receivable may have been promised elsewhere.

Their incentives are not identical to yours. You are trying to keep production moving. They are trying to preserve repayment if production stalls or a customer disputes delivery. Experienced investors understand this tension. They do not regard a lender’s exclusions as administrative irritations. They ask whether the operating system is strong enough to survive those exclusions.

That is why a strong founder does not merely pitch revenue. They can explain exactly which invoices qualify, which do not, where stock sits, who owns it, and what happens when a customer pays late.

Build the file before you need the money

Start with an order-level cash schedule. Map customer deposits, supplier milestones, conversion costs, scrap, delivery and collection dates week by week. Identify the peak gap.

Then build an eligibility schedule before the lender does. Separate aged debt, disputes, credit notes, related-party balances, concentration excess, work in progress, consignment stock and slow inventory. Give each exclusion an owner and a remedy.

Finally, create a proof trail for every financed invoice: signed order, dispatch record, delivery evidence, acceptance, invoice and customer payment into the controlled account. If one link cannot be independently verified, treat it as a funding risk.

GI Network's view: The best working-capital application is an operating file disguised as a finance file. A lender can work with a difficult production cycle when order evidence, supplier payments, stock records, acceptance documents and collections all reconcile. It cannot lend confidently against optimism, however commercially reasonable that optimism may be.

GI Network would test the cash-conversion schedule against the proposed facility, identify which receivables and inventory will be excluded, assess whether supplier-payment finance, receivables finance or a blended structure fits each stage, and rehearse the objections a credit committee will raise about acceptance, concentration, stock ownership and collections. For a business preparing to fund confirmed production, apply for Capital with the order book, debtor ageing and stock records ready for that scrutiny.

The Controlled Conversion Test

Before seeking finance for a material order, ask eight questions:

  1. 1.Cash gap: What is the weekly peak funding need after deposits, supplier milestones, conversion costs and scrap?
  2. 2.Asset stage: Are you asking for money against a verified order, controlled stock or an accepted invoice?
  3. 3.Proof: Can an independent party verify order, dispatch, delivery, acceptance and payment source?
  4. 4.Eligibility: Which debt is aged, disputed, concentrated, related-party or otherwise excluded?
  5. 5.Stock reality: Which stock is finished, owned, located, saleable and not committed elsewhere?
  6. 6.Proceeds: Do customer payments route into the required controlled account or deed-of-cession arrangement?
  7. 7.Production risk: Have you shown supplier dependence, material ownership, capacity, lead times and scrap recovery?
  8. 8.True cost: Have you modelled the facility through the actual collection date, including fees and legal treatment?

If the answer to one question is “we can explain it”, rather than “here is the document”, the conversion is not yet controlled.

ShareWhatsAppLinkedInX
Questions people ask

I won the contract. How do I fund it?

A confirmed contract can support funding only when the lender can verify and control the path from supplier payment to customer collection. Purchase-order finance may pay approved suppliers directly before production. After delivery and customer acceptance, receivables finance may become available. Prepare the order, supplier terms, production plan, material ownership records, dispatch evidence, customer acceptance and a clear payment route.

What is working capital finance?

Working capital finance funds the conversion of cash spent on materials, production and operating costs into cash collected from customers. It can be linked to a purchase order, eligible invoices or qualifying inventory. Lenders do not usually fund the full order value or accounting balance. They assess whether the underlying assets, production process and customer payment can be independently verified and controlled.

What are the main working capital options in South Africa?

Options discussed in the article include purchase-order finance, receivables finance, factoring and inventory-backed lending. Purchase-order finance can fund approved supplier payments before production. Receivables finance is generally available after goods are delivered and accepted. Factoring may suit businesses with weaker internal controls because the funder administers the sales ledger and collections. Inventory lending depends on ownership, location, condition and saleability.

How much working capital finance can a small business get?

The amount depends on eligible assets and the timing of the cash shortfall, not simply the contract value or facility limit. In one example, a R10 million order created a peak funding need of R6.4 million. Receivables may be advanced at up to 80% after exclusions for aged, disputed, uninsured, related-party or concentrated debt. Inventory is usually discounted further for work in progress, obsolete stock and production risk.

Do I need collateral?

Not always in the conventional sense, but lenders still need security and control over repayment. A purchase-order facility may rely on validated orders, direct payment to approved suppliers and a customer payment cession. Receivables finance can require collections to flow into a bank-managed account. For inventory, lenders need evidence of title, location, condition and value. Financial records, cash flow and operating controls can matter more than nominal collateral.

Sources
  • Provincial Government Purchase Order Funding Solution · Standard Bank · Not stated
  • IDC Development Report 2018–2022 · Industrial Development Corporation · 2018–2022
  • Merchant Commercial Finance v Katana Foods · Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa · December 2017
  • Movable Asset-Based Lending in Zambia: Market Study · World Bank · 2019
  • Master Trading v CapX Finance · High Court of Namibia · 26 January 2021
  • Lessons from Greensill Capital · UK Parliament Treasury Committee · Not stated
  • Founder of Hin Leong Trading Sentenced and Jailed for Cheating and Instigating Forgery · Singapore Police Force · November 2024
  • Working Capital Solutions · Absa · Not stated
  • Purchase Order Finance · Absa Botswana · Not stated
  • provincial government purchase order funding solution | Standard Bank
  • World Bank Document
  • Case study VM Automotive aspires to be a supplier
  • Merchant Commercial Finance (Pty) Ltd v Katana Foods CC (1238/2016) [2017] ZASCA 191 (20 December 2017)
  • Practice Directive 61
  • Lessons from Greensill Capital - Treasury Committee - House of Commons
  • SPF | Founder Of Hin Leong Trading Sentenced And Jailed For Cheating And Instigating Forgery
  • Absa | Working Capital Trade solutions
  • Purchase Order Finance
Reviewed by the GI Advisory Team
GI Network

Apply for Capital to structure a working capital facility matched to your order book and receivables quality.

Apply for Capital

Seeking capital?

Your application is the first step into the GI Network capital process.

Apply for Capital